Thursday, 26 November 2009

The lies to stop believing

This wise looking character is my friend Aboodi. He's a very fine coach and (amongst other things) I admire the way he goes against the happy-clappier elements in the coaching world and proposes something more realistic and grounded.

He's recently started his weekly newsletter Stirring the Soul up again, and I thought I'd share last weeks with you. To sign up yourself, go here, and here's his blog, and here's where he tweets.

Thanks Bood, good to have you back. Here's what he said...

*

In this issue, I want to take a look at one of the ideas I've been working on, along the lines of "lies to stop believing".

For a long time now, I've been uncomfortable with some aspects of the personal development movement, with its focus on positive thinking and unlimited possibility, and, if you like, the "shadow" side of that, and its connection with entitlement, something I've written about often.

It's increasingly my view that entitlement is one of the biggest challenges we face, both as individuals, and as a society, and at the root of many of the problems we face, and it's a theme I will be returning to often.

The personal development world, in particular, makes many claims about the kind of life that is possible for us, if we follow certain routes, or buy certain books/workshops/coaching, etc.. Some of these claims speak directly to beliefs that we hold about life, too.

There's nothing wrong with aspirations, or wanting 'a better life', but I think we have come to hold these aspirations as expectations - the idea that we are somehow entitled to them, and that, if only we do the right thing, those expectations will come true.

I call these claims "lies to stop believing", because I have found, both in my own life, and those of the people with whom I work, that there is a lot of suffering caused by the disappointment when these expectations aren't met.

What are some of these "lies"?

Some day, my prince(ss) will come. Not necessarily - many people face a lifetime of not meeting their prince or princess. An increasing number of us might have to face a future of growing old alone, and accept that there isn't "someone out there, just for me".

You can make your dreams come true. You probably can't. This is one of the ones I hear and read about most often, and perhaps one of the most insidious. Yes, we can aspire to fulfil our dreams, but we need to be grounded in the reality that most of us aren't going to be able to have the 'life we always dreamed of'.

Things will get better. No, they might not. This might be 'as good as it gets'.

If you build it, they will come. Again, they might not.

I deserve better than this. Perhaps, most harshly of all, why? Deserving is absolutely tied up with entitlement, and it's a myth that I deserve anything - it's an act of sheer good fortune that I have the comfortable life I have, and am not living on the streets of Rio de Janeiro, or languishing in a prison-cell in Baghdad.

Sorry to be so blunt, but there it is - life is unfair. The good guy doesn't always get the girl, and the bad guy sometimes wins. We can have our dreams, do our affirmations, practice chanting and meditating on our goals, do the work, network, go on plenty of dates, and still not get what we long for.

This might sound negative, defeatist even, especially from a coach, but I want to suggest that acceptance of the possibility that we might not get what we long for is also a route to peace.

When I accept that life isn't necessarily going to bring me what I long for (of course it might, but it equally might not), then I have the possibility to ask different questions about life, and to navigate with what is, rather than the striving for, and pain of disappointment if I don't get, what I yearn for.

What if I am single for the rest of my days? What if I never write that book I've been meaning to write? What if my life never gets any "better" than this? What then?

For me, this is deeply connected with the Buddhist ideals of non-attachment. Have goals, by all means. Apply yourself to them with passion and zeal. But the real practice is to accept that you might not live the life you expect to lead, or feel entitled to have. And, yes, there is a paradox there.

In addition, there are many other dimensions to this - the implications for others when we give up our entitlement, the cultural idea that we are somehow responsible or, worse, actually "to blame" if we don't have a perfect life (unfortunately sometimes disseminated by parts of the personal development world), etc, and, as I said this is a theme I will be returning to frequently.

For now, though, some reflections.
What "lies" do you believe?What has been the cost to you of those? What happens when you accept that you might not get what you want (or what you think you deserve)? What then?

Sometimes what seems like surrender isn't surrender at all. It's about what's going on in our hearts. About seeing clearly the way life is and accepting it and being true to it, whatever the pain, because the pain of not being true to it is far, far greater.
Nicholas Evans, The Horse Whisperer

You are not a precious and unique snowflake; you are the same decaying organic matter as everything else.
Tyler Durden in Fight Club

13 comments:

michelle said...

"Things will get better. No, they might not. This might be 'as good as it gets'"

I could not agree with you more on this. Life is what it is each day - tomorrow could be better or it could be worse.

Enjoy what you have today, right.this.moment because we have no control over what is next.

I liked the honesty of this post. I get so TIRED of reading blogs that are all sunshiny all the time. They seem fake to me. No one is happy all of the time and even the most self aware people have really bad days when a negative thought or two crosses their mind.

Terresa said...

This is a realist post, grounded in honesty and truth.

I really loved "Fight Club." It was eye opening for me in many ways.

A few years ago a silly book came out about imagining a $20 bill or a feather. This book (forgot the title) claimed that if you visualized these physical items enough, they would magically materialize in your life.

Uh, right.

The fact that people bought this book and then adhered to it's teachings, hoping and waiting for the $20 or feather, is a tragedy.

We need to work each day for what we have, taking nothing for granted. And at the same time, not be so attached to the physical that we can't see past it (does that make sense?).

Thought provoking post, Fiona, as always.

Rachel said...

Terresa - was that The Secret. Kind of sounds like it (imagine the cheque for £25,000 and it will come... yup, whatever, still waiting!! :D)

Fiona - the timing of your post couldn't be more perfect as these are things I have been trying to articulate myself. And I couldn't agree more.

The happy-clappy sunshine brigade are one of the reasons I gave up full time yoga teaching (that and the egos, although I think the two are very closely linked). I have fibromyalgia and scoliosis. I am in pain a lot of the time and I am not miraculously going to think myself better. Attitude helps me manage my day to day life admittedly but it's not going to make me better.

One could then go down the "Why Me" line. Why do I have to suffer. But I just think "Why Not Me?" Why do I feel I deserve something other than this. Make the most of what you've got and try to find a little contentment I say.

Life is in flux constantly. We can be self aware but it won't take the bad days away forever. The bad days, I find, make the good days even better. Nothing lasts forever, but this joy will also pass.

Fiona Robyn said...

Thank you Michelle, Terresa and Rachel for your thoughts on Aboodi's thoughts. It's tempting to think we can always 'look on the positive side', but I think, as you say, that this means we miss out on a lot of potential richness and learning.

I'm sure there will always be lots of market for the happy-clappy brigade, and good luck to them! but give me some light with darkness mixed in any day...

Dale said...

Yay Fiona! Absolutely.

Another thing about the "anything is possible" view is that ultimately it makes all of our misfortunes into moral failures. If we're not rich, famous, fabulously paired up, and regularly winning nobel prizes, it can only be because we haven't visualized it enough, haven't wanted it enough, haven't been positive enough. It's really much more devastating than just suffering misfortune. Not only are we unhappy: we must bear the burden of knowing we've willed our unhappiness. And if we're betraying ourselves on that deep a level, what hope can there possibly be for us?

Causes and conditions: everything in Samsara comes about because of causes and conditions, including "me." Buddhist promises a staggering amount of freedom, but it's not freedom from causes and conditions. Even the Buddha didn't have that much chutzpah :-)

Marie said...

Perfection for this moment; just what I needed.

deb said...

Loved this. And may I add that I wonder how this culture of telling kids everything they do is over the top awesome will further the entitlement mindset , as well as vulnerable self esteems. That parents were suppose to be protecting in the first place.
I try to tell my children that life is unfair sometimes.
anyway... rambling , but I've been thinking about this lately.

kathleen said...

I love the honesty of this post. And I agree that the excessive media hype about the magical powers of positive thinking and creative visualisation is a little over the top. I think what the Secret failed to emphasise was that positive thinking and visualisation is merely a step in a process towards achieving a goal. Positive thinking without inspired action is hardly going to produce anything worthwhile. If we place too much emphasis on imagination and too little on good old fashioned hard work we're unlikely to get very far. Nonetheless I do believe that with a positive attitude and a clear vision one is more likely to have the courage, energy and inspiration that is required to move forward. And maintaining a positive attitude in the face of adversity is a lot more helpful than giving up and getting depressed. Our challenges are usually our biggest teachers and I've found that the most difficult times of my life have made me stronger and more courageous..
thanks for a thought provoking post.

Fiona Robyn said...

Dale - I love the idea of the Buddha having chutzpah - such a glorious word! I bet he had it in spades, but as you say, it's all about causes and conditions.

Good, Marie. And yes Deb, I agree.

Kathleen - important not to throw the baby out with the bathwater as you say. 'our challenges are our biggest teachers' - yes.

Fiona Robyn said...

PS Kathleen - welcome to Planting Words!

Fiona Robyn said...

PS Kathleen - welcome to Planting Words!

kathleen said...

Thanks Fiona - it's great to be here!

Allie said...

What a fantastic post! I think the uncertainty is part of the wonders of life and I really hate it when people sanitize it out of everything. I like to celebrate it. It's okay to be unhappy sometimes and it's okay to work hard and try for things even when you might not succeed.